Best and worst MINI Cooper S years to buy
Every model year, judged against the others.
Gathering every model year from NHTSA. The first look at a model can take a little while.
Every model year, judged against the others.
Gathering every model year from NHTSA. The first look at a model can take a little while.
NHTSA did not answer for model years 1995 to 2001, 2018, 2023, 2026 and 2027, so any with records are missing here. For 2002, 2003, 2005 to 2007, 2011 to 2014, 2016, 2022 and 2024, NHTSA answered only in part, so some counts say “No answer”. The verdicts may change once NHTSA answers. Try again in a minute.
Look for 2008, 2009 and 2020. Skip 2004 and 2015. Careful with 2010.
Of the newer years to look for, the ones with the fewest owner complaints for their age. A year few people bought can look the same.
From owner complaints filed with NHTSA. Only years old enough to judge. Still have any car inspected.
The most recent judged years that came out Worthy.
Other Worthy years with the fewest owner complaints against a typical year at the same age. A year with few sales can look the same.
Every Worthy year of the Cooper S is in the newest ones above.
Judged years with enough more complaints than a typical year to reach Maybe or Pass.
Education, not financial or mechanical advice. Have any used car checked by a mechanic you trust before you buy.
Each year’s owner complaints, held up against a typical year of the Cooper S at the same age. Popular cars collect more complaints just by selling more, so a year is never compared with another model.
Tap a year to open it. Bars are owner complaints filed with NHTSA: unverified, and not adjusted for how many were sold. The three small marks by a year show how sure its verdict is: three for high, one for low. How sure is the verdict?
SourceNHTSA’s complaint and recall datasets. Each year’s page links its own NHTSA record. NHTSA, checked Nov 3, 2026.
9.6× a typical year
173 vs 18 typical
Most named: Steering
“Do not drive” and “park outside” are NHTSA’s own warnings on a recall, until it is fixed.
Scroll the table sideways to see more.
| Year | Verdict | Owner complaints | Recalls | Top problem area |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | Not judged | 4 | 3 | Brakes |
| 2024 | Not judged | 1 | No answer | Engine |
| 2022 | Not judged | 1 | No answer | Electrical |
| 2021 | Not judged | 0 | 2 | None on file |
| 2020 | Worthy | 5 | 2 | Engine |
| 2019 | Not judged | 4 | 1 | Electrical |
| 2017 | Not judged | 4 | 3 | Air bags |
| 2016 | Not judged | No answer | 3 | No answer |
| 2015 | Pass | 71 | 4 | Engine |
| 2014 | Not judged | No answer | 4 | No answer |
| 2013 | Not judged | No answer | 1 | No answer |
| 2012 | Not judged | No answer | 2 | No answer |
| 2011 | Not judged | No answer | 3 | No answer |
| 2010 | Maybe | 59 | 4 | Engine |
| 2009 | Worthy | 36 | 3 | Engine |
| 2008 | Worthy | 16 | 4 | Air bags |
| 2007 | Not judged | No answer | 4 | No answer |
| 2006 | Not judged | No answer | 1 | No answer |
| 2005 | Not judged | No answer | 2 | No answer |
| 2004 | Pass | 529 | 2 | Steering |
| 2003 | Not judged | No answer | 2 | No answer |
| 2002 | Not judged | No answer | 1 | No answer |
SourceNHTSA’s complaint and recall datasets. Each year’s page links its own NHTSA record. NHTSA, checked Nov 3, 2026.